Egg and calculator on a record-keeping desk

Hens Eating Eggs: Why It Starts and How to Stop It

Why hens start eating their own eggs, how to find the culprit, and what to change in nests, feed and collection so the habit goes away.

Egg eating starts by accident: an egg cracks, a hen tastes it — and likes it. The others learn quickly from the first, and a month later you’re collecting a third fewer eggs though the hens lay as before. The habit is easier to prevent than to break, but it can be broken.

How to tell they’re eating eggs

If collection fell but there are no traces, the cause is probably something else: why hens stopped laying.

Why it starts

CauseWhat to do
Thin shells, eggs break on their ownCheck calcium and vitamin D (on shells)
Too few nests, crowdingOne nest per 4–5 hens
Bright nestsShade with a curtain or move to a dark corner
Infrequent collectionCollect 2–3 times a day
Too little nest materialA thick layer of shavings or straw
Lack of protein, boredomComplete feed, something for hens to do

How to break the habit

  1. Find the culprit. Often one or two hens with yolk on their beaks. Put them in a separate pen for 1–2 weeks.
  2. Collect eggs at once. In the morning and early afternoon, while most of the flock is laying, check nests every hour or two.
  3. Use dummy eggs. Wooden, ceramic or plastic eggs in the nests. A hen pecks, gets nothing, and loses interest.
  4. Remove broken eggs immediately together with the soiled nest material.
  5. Install roll-away nests. The egg rolls down a sloped floor behind a partition the hen can’t reach. The most reliable fix when the problem persists.

About the “mustard egg”

The old advice is to blow out an egg and fill it with mustard or hot pepper. Sometimes it helps, but it’s unreliable and doesn’t fix the cause. Unless you sort out shells, nests and collection, the habit comes back.

If nothing works

A hen that eats eggs for months and teaches others costs you money. In that case she’s culled. Unpleasant, but sensible on a farm that counts eggs.

How much you’re losing

Compare collection in EggPulse with the usual laying rate for the flock’s age. If the rate has dropped while the hens look healthy and are laying, the gap is roughly what’s being eaten in the nests. Broken eggs at collection can be logged separately too.